“It was not appropriate,” laughs Ricamora.
Imagine the cast ofHow to Get Away With Murdershowing up at your wedding.
That killer surprise happened to one lucky couple but it perhaps didn’t go the way one might expect.

Jack Falahee and Conrad Ricamora in ‘How to Get Away With Murder’.ABC
ABC
“This was around the time where we were the Keating Five,” Falahee remembers.
“We took a staycation somewhere just outside of L.A., and we had dinner reservations in a hotel.
Adds Ricamora (needlessly): “We had been drinking a little.”

Conrad Ricamora and Jack Falahee in ‘How to Get Away With Murder’.Richard Cartwright/Walt Disney Television via Getty Images
“Of course, people were like, ‘What is going on?'”
“It was not appropriate,” Ricamora notes.
“I sang ‘Creep’ byRadioheadat somebody’s wedding.
Drunk on the piano, that was the only song that I could remember how to plunk out.
And then, Aja sits down next to me and starts belting it out.”
The entireHTGAWMcast is relatively musical, but Ricamora has appeared in multiple Broadway musicals.
But Falahee remembers the desire to warble a tune being somewhat irrepressible among the Keating Five.
“AndThe Today Showor something wanted us to singLes Mison the air.
It’ll be a two-hour interview.'”
Frankly, we kinda wish we could’ve seen that.