“I mean, one of your insurance companies will figure it out,” Marsden hesitantly replied.

Mat Hayward/WireImage; Monica Schipper/WireImage

Eiza Gonzalezis putting her friendship withJames Marsdento the test.

Uh, heres what I think.

Eiza Gonzalez asks James Marsden

Eiza Gonzalez; James Marsden.Credit:Mat Hayward/WireImage; Monica Schipper/WireImage

Like I totaled the car.

However, he only gave Gonzalez more prank fodder in the process.

Do you think hes gonna sue me?

Eiza Gonzalez attends the 2025 Vanity Fair Oscar Party

Gonzalez.Taylor Hill/FilmMagic

Do you think hes gonna ask me to pay for it?

A flustered Marsden explained thatsomeonewill likely have to pay for the damages.

Can you pay for it for me?

Gonzalez asked, bursting into laughter as she sent him into an even deeper spiral.

I think youre just gonna have to… “Which… but… hes a friend and hell understand and it was an accident.

But Gonzalez didn’t let him off the hook that easy.

Marsden, on the other hand, didnt find the scenario nearly as funny.

Oh my God, what?

Well, I guess, I mean…

He paused, then added, Are you f—ing with me?

What the f—?

A laughing Gonzalez then confirmed to Marsden that he’d just been pranked.

Youre gonna give me a f—ing heart attack!

Im like, what the hell.

What if I said, Do not bring it up, baby, just hit the road!

Ooh, he replied.

My creative juices are already spinning.

Watch Gonzalez prank Marsden and herAshcostar Aaron Paul in the video above.